Home > Author > Patricia Crone >

" Did the latter[The Messenger] have a predecessor, who envisaged
revelation as taking place by direct contact with a divine being rather than by
a book being sent down (whether as a whole or in instalments), who claimed
to have enjoyed such contact himself and who objected to the pagan angels—
not because they violated the dividing line between God and created beings
but rather because they were female? We do not hear of such a predecessor
elsewhere in the Quran, but we do learn that the Messenger had competitors in
his own time, at least in Yathrib (2:79, where they share his concept of revelation
as a book), so there is nothing implausible about the proposition that there
were preachers before him too, including some whose preaching anticipated
features of his own. "

Patricia Crone , The Qurʾānic Pagans and Related Matters


Image for Quotes

Patricia Crone quote : Did the latter[The Messenger] have a predecessor, who envisaged<br />revelation as taking place by direct contact with a divine being rather than by<br />a book being sent down (whether as a whole or in instalments), who claimed<br />to have enjoyed such contact himself and who objected to the pagan angels—<br />not because they violated the dividing line between God and created beings<br />but rather because they were female? We do not hear of such a predecessor<br />elsewhere in the Quran, but we do learn that the Messenger had competitors in<br />his own time, at least in Yathrib (2:79, where they share his concept of revelation<br />as a book), so there is nothing implausible about the proposition that there<br />were preachers before him too, including some whose preaching anticipated<br />features of his own.